Amrita Datta’s Stories of the Indian Immigrant Communities in Germany: Why Move? (published by Palgrave Macmillan) in 2023 goes beyond a simple answer to the titular question. This compelling book delves deeper, using personal narratives to illuminate the multifaceted motivations and challenges faced by Indian immigrants in Germany from the context of current socio-political times. Datta, a sociologist and a migration scholar, utilizes a blend of participant observation, autoethnography, and in-depth interviews to weave a rich mix of experiences, revealing the complexities and nuances of Indian migration.
Shifting the Focus
Datta breaks from the traditional narrative of migration studies, which often focuses on economic factors and policy frameworks. Instead, she centres the human stories at the heart of the discussion. Through the experiences of students, Information technology (IT) professionals, activists, and women escaping gendered violence, the book explores the diverse reasons pushing individuals to leave India and choose Germany as a new home. An interesting array of stories depicts multifaceted sides of emigration in the current times.
A Tapestry of Motivations
The “pandemic and politics” emerge as key drivers for some. Fear of persecution for activism or a yearning for a more inclusive environment compels others. The allure of career opportunities and a higher standard of living is a factor for some, while for others, it’s the quest for a more secure future for their families. Datta’s nuanced approach reveals that migration is rarely a singular choice; it’s a complex web of personal aspirations, societal pressures, and global forces and stories of friendships across boundaries and time.
Beyond the Blue Card
The book extends its gaze beyond the stereotypical “highly skilled migrant” category, often associated with EU Blue Card holders. It explores the experiences of students who may face financial difficulties and uncertainties around their future careers. It also delves into the realities of those navigating “shadow migration pathways,” highlighting the struggles of those who may face a more precarious existence.
Creating “Home” in Germany
While some immigrants experience a sense of belonging and acceptance in Germany, the book also acknowledges the challenges associated with creating a “home” in a new cultural landscape. Datta utilizes the concept of “transcultural practices” to showcase how Indian immigrants strive to maintain ties to their heritage while integrating into German society. This includes celebrating traditional festivals, forming community networks, and navigating language barriers.
The Shadow of Racism
However, the path to “homing” is not without obstacles. Datta critically examines the presence of structural and everyday symbolic racism that certain Indian immigrants face. This might manifest as difficulties in finding housing, discrimination in the workplace, or microaggressions encountered in daily life. These experiences highlight the ongoing struggle for equal opportunities and acceptance for immigrants, even within seemingly “welcoming” societies.
Reflexivity and the Researcher’s Role
Datta’s own experiences as a migrant scholar from India residing in Germany add a layer of insightful reflexivity to the book. She acknowledges the inherent power dynamics in researching the experiences of others and emphasizes the importance of building trust and respectful relationships with her interviewees. This approach fosters a sense of authenticity and allows the reader to connect with the stories on a deeper level.
A Call for Empathy and Understanding
“Stories of the Indian Immigrant Communities in Germany” stands as a powerful call for empathy and understanding in the discourse on migration. By moving beyond statistics and highlighting the human stories, Datta compels readers to recognize the multifaceted motivations and challenges faced by immigrants.
The Book’s Significance
This book is a valuable contribution to the field of migration studies, particularly relevant in the current global context. It offers a unique perspective on the experiences of Indian immigrants in Germany, a destination attracting growing numbers of migrants from South Asia. Furthermore, the book’s exploration of diverse motivations, challenges, and pathways transcends geographical boundaries and resonates with the wider conversation on human mobility and integration.
Looking Forward
Datta’s work paves the way for further research into the social and cultural dimensions of Indian migration in Germany. It begs further analysis of the role of technology, the evolving political landscape, and changing societal attitudes towards immigration. Ultimately, “Stories of the Indian Immigrant Communities in Germany” serves as a powerful reminder that migration is a complex human phenomenon driven by a multitude of factors, adding a contemporary layer to the stories of migration – transnational, intranational, intercontinental, transcontinental and so on. A valuable contribution and an interesting new layer to the facets of human migration continuing from the beginning of humanity.
***
Aruna Bhattacharya is the lead of Academics and Research at the Indian Institute for Human Settlements (IIHS) in Bengaluru, India and is currently engaged with the School of Human Development building up the urban health and public health component.